Book first, then movie has been the rule in our house for as long as I can remember. I remember my mother whispering it to me when I begged her to let me watch The Wizard Of Oz for the first time.
“Nan, you only get to experience the story for the first time ONCE! Book first, then movie! You will likely love the movie, but you’ll adore the book.” she said. She said it which such an authoritative tone that I knew better than to argue with her.
She called me Nan, but you can call me NJ. My real name is Nancyjo.
And that is the way my childhood went.
Click To Tweet
Malone and I recently had the opportunity to sink our teeth into the book Charlie And The Chocolate Factory by Roald Dahl. When we were finished with the book, we watched the movie. This post was inspired by the 50th anniversary of Roald Dahl’s Charlie And The Chocolate Factory. Malone and I received a copy of the book from the publisher. All opinions are our own. There are affiliate links present within this post.
10 Reasons To Read The Book First And Then Watch The Movie
1. You only get to experience a story for the first time once.
2. Unless it is a picture book, a book gives a richer version of the story and plot than a movie.
Click To Tweet
3. Reading the book first and then watching the movie will give you an inside track to what is about to happen. But at the same time, you won’t know EXACTLY how it is done in the movie. The sorting hat scene in Harry Potter comes to mind here. I knew it was coming in the movie, but I was amazed at how the movie portrayed it.
4. Amazing visual details from the book come to life on the big screen. Often times, the way a movie translates details of the book are much more visually stunning than what I pictured when I read the book. The example that sticks out to me the most is the flame dress that Katniss wore in The Hunger Games.
5. You can really understand what is motivating a character. I love that books are often written in such a way that we get to “hear” what exactly is going on inside a person’s head. This doesn’t happen much in the movies at all. And if it did, the movie would be TOO long!
6. Speaking of long movies, by reading a book first and then watching the movie, you get the full story! Nothing about the plot has been cut out to make sure it fits into the allotted time frame.
7. The book will be true to itself but the movie director might take entertainment liberties and change the story up to make it more appealing to a movie audience. I can’t tell you how many movies based on a book that I’ve been to where the ending isn’t the same as it is in the book!
Click To Tweet
8. You can take your experience further by comparing and contrasting the book and the movie. This is especially great if you are working through a book first then watching the movie with your kids.
9. There is nothing like getting hooked into a good book. All of the production budget in the world cannot buy the experience of falling in love with a good book.
10. You’ll get bragging rights! You can be one of those people who can claim they loved the book more than the movie.
This post was inspired by the classic Charlie and the Chocolate Factory by Roald Dahl, which celebrates its 50th anniversary this year. To celebrate, Penguin Young Readers Group, in partnership with Dylanโs Candy Bar, the world-famous candy emporium, and First Book, a nonprofit social enterprise that provides books for children from low-income families, is launching a year-long international celebration.
Head over to From Left to Write to learn how you and your child can have a chance to win the Golden Ticket Sweepstakes where the grand prize is a magical trip to New York City plus much more! For every entry submitted, Penguin Young Readers Group will make a donation to First Book. Then, join From Left to Write on July 24 as we discuss Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. As a book club member, I received a copy of the book for review purposes.
Join the newsletter
Living in MA rocks! Subscribe to hear about awesome events and places to explore with your family.
Truly couldn’t agree more NJ and I am am one of those people who can honestly say I have read the book (Charlie and the Chocolate Factory way before I, too, watched the movie back when I was a young kid and will totally be reading the book with my girls before they see the movie, too ๐
Janine Huldie recently posted..Emma’s Frozen 5th Birthday Party Celebration
I always read the book first and have continued that with my sons. I remember ET as being one of the first and my son came out of the movie and pointed out all of the ‘errors” in it…but he still cried when ET died; or didn’t.
LindySez recently posted..Zucchini Ricotta Torta
I’ve always wondered what NJ stood for! I try to read the book before I see the movie as well, and I look forward to reading some wonderful classics (such as Charlie & the Chocolate Factory) with Eve before we watch the movie together ๐
Bev recently posted..{DIY} How to make a travel art kit for kids
While I am not a strict “book first, then movie” adherent, it really bugs me when editions that are published after the movie have a cover based on the movie! Drives me nuts… LOL
Nancy recently posted..The Original is Always Better.
oh gosh the flame dress Katniss wore was so amazing in the movie! I could not for the life of me visualize it when I read the book so the movie really helped! Same with the sorting hat – such a great scene! Love this list!
STacy (The Novel Life) recently posted..5 Life Lessons from Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Ah, Roald Dahl…I loved so many of his books when I was a kid! Charlie and the Chocolate Factory was one of my brother’s favorites, too. I’ve been guilty of watching the movie before reading a book, but it really is best to read the book first. If you read the book first, your imagination gets to run wild with how the characters look and all those other details, but seeing the movie first fills in too many of those blanks and can really keep you from having that fun.
Leslie recently posted..{Weigh in Wednesday} Week 82
Haha on the last one, bragging rights. I love that! I watched HG before reading the 1st and 2nd books. BUT I read the 3rd one first and I can’t wait for the movie! I think that all of the stuff going on in Katniss’ will definitely not be able to be portrayed in the movie so I’m glad I got the inside scoop. A book-turned-movie that I kinda refuse to see is “The Host”, written originally by Stephanie Meyer. If you’ve read it, you’ll know what I mean.
lisacng @ expandng.com recently posted..I only make these cookies twice a year
I wholeheartedly agree! This has always been my rule, but it’s often hard to find the time to get around to reading the book before the movie now that I’m a parent. So many details are lost when taking a book to film, and each is an art form in itself. I’ve often found that reading the book first made the film easier to follow, The English Patient being an example that comes to mind.
Lauren Stevens recently posted..That Time I Spent $100 On An IKEA Stuffed Cat
[…] Welcome NJ from A Cookie Before Dinner. Her real name is Nancyjo, and she writes stuff like Read the book first and the post that hooked me to her — The dirty things you’d find in my mom-car. So […]
There have been a few instances where the movie was better than the book…however! I think all your points are completely true. Even if the movie is better, there is a reason they made a movie out of the book! Its because the book is GoOD!
alyssaz recently posted..The Butterfly and the Violin
[…] NJ from A Cookie Before Dinner gives 10 reasons why you should read a book before watching the movie version. […]
This is such a great list of reasons to read the book first! I often find it hard to find the desire to read the book AFTER I’ve watched the movie. My real reason is, like you mentioned, you get to see it portrayed vividly on screen. I also really enjoy being able to focus more of the details on screen since I already know the plot. Such a great organization to support!
[…] 1. Grilled Zucchini with Italian Marinade – A Dish of Daily Life / 2. 6 Netflix Shows Your Toddler Will LOVE! – 100lb Countdown / 3. Book First, Then Movie – A Cookie Before Dinner […]
[…] 1. The Ultimate Breakfast Hot Dog – Frugal Mom Eh! / 2. Nutella Snowball Cookies – Upstate Ramblings / 3. Fancy Nancy Birthday Party – Love, Laughter, Foreverafter […]
[…] 5. We read the book before we watch the movie. […]